hrtechoutlookapac

Survey: Only 48.6% of Employers Think Their Job Ads Are Effective

HR Tech Outlook | Wednesday, December 06, 2023

Love it or hate it, writing a job ad is a key piece of the recruiting process. Without a captivating, well-crafted ad, attracting top candidates is nearly impossible. However, developing a job ad can be time-consuming, requiring the right blend of research, keywords, and persuasive language to convince candidates to click “apply.”

Hiring and HR professionals never seem to have enough hours in a day, and not everyone is a natural-born writer. So, how are today’s employers managing their job ad development process? Do they really know how to create a job posting? What challenges are they experiencing, and how effective do they believe their postings are in recruiting the right candidates?

Stay ahead of the industry with exclusive feature stories on the top companies, expert insights and the latest news delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.

For answers to these questions and more, we polled 216 employers from our client base who are directly involved in creating job ads for their organization. Our survey findings are as follows.

How Long Does It Take to Write a Job Ad?

First, we asked employers to estimate how long it typically takes them to write a job ad from scratch. Nearly half (47.2%) of respondents said they spend more than 30 minutes creating an ad, with 13.9% taking more than an hour. That time adds up, especially when you’re wearing multiple hats and juggling various HR and recruiting tasks.

Luckily, writing a job ad from scratch is not always necessary with the help of templates and generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools. While 67.6% of employers said they use a job posting template at least some of the time, just 10.2% use AI (like ChatGPT) to assist in creating their ads “always” or “most of the time.”

Challenges Writing a Job Ad

Finding the time to write a job ad, however, was not as big of a struggle as knowing which information to include to attract the right talent – this was the top challenge respondents cited (56.0%).

Further, 46.8% grapple with writing the ad so that it “sells” their company, and 41.7% are often unsure about which information from the job description to include in their posting.

What Information to Include in a Job Ad

Although employers were uncertain which information to include in their ad, most do comprise the most critical details: The majority of respondents said they always include candidate requirements and qualifications (78.2%), location of the job (76.4%), and benefits (63.4%).

While 56.6% always include the salary range, that percentage should be higher – as previous research has shown, listing the salary for a position increases the likelihood of a candidate applying for a job.

Job Ad Creation Best Practices

Next, we asked employers to identify the best practices they always follow when creating a new job ad. We were glad to see most employers were conscious of spelling and grammar errors – which can be a major candidate turnoff – but were surprised that less than half of review their ad for potentially biased or discriminatory language (47.2%) and research and include fair and competitive salary ranges when developing their ad (46.3%).

Job Ad Effectiveness

How effective do employers think their job ads are in attracting the right candidates? Respondents were fairly confident in their postings, as 48.6% said their ads were “very effective” or “effective.” At the same time, 42.6% said their ads were just “somewhat effective,” and only 4.2% said they were “not effective.”

Despite confidence in their ads’ efficacy, half (49.1%) of employers do not track any metrics – such as view-to-apply rates, application completion rates, and total applies – to determine how well their job ads are attracting qualified candidates.

Additionally, 46.3% of employers do not ensure their ad follows SEO best practices so the right talent finds them in search results. However, the best job postings include keywords, such as the career titles, location, and required skills a candidate may search for while on the hunt for a new position.

 
 

More in News

 Organizations recognize the importance of attracting and developing skilled employees. To achieve strong employee engagement in a hybrid work setting, companies must focus on effective digital transformation efforts. Businesses must differentiate their brand image and enhance employee satisfaction with competitive pay and benefits. To promote greater emotional connections with their workforce, employers need to encourage active participation from employees. As personalization grows in significance, companies should integrate a diverse array of advanced digital technologies to deliver a seamless employee experience. Leveraging Learning and Development Tools With the introduction of the digital coaching program, several businesses have recently branched out from traditional methods of workplace learning. As we transition to hybrid working, investing in soft skills through strategies like coaching has become more crucial than ever. Professional development programs are an effective tool to empower employees by allowing them to continually upgrade their skills in line with new trends and job roles. This improves the talent pool in the organization but enhances employees' workplace experience by ensuring they are constantly growing and developing. Depending on their personality, professionals can choose the best coach using digital solutions that leverage artificial intelligence (AI). Organizing workshops and establishing long-term objectives are the first steps in the mentoring relationship between trainers and employees. The trainer develops a learning program for the employees after evaluating their areas of strength and improvement opportunities. Then, the performance is monitored and evaluated based on predetermined goals and benchmarks. Curated Communication Methods Most businesses operate in a hybrid model nowadays, so face-to-face meetings between coworkers occur less frequently. Businesses and employees can profit greatly from working remotely, but there are some limitations like communication. As a starting point, businesses utilize the software application provided by their management to review and leverage targeted communication solutions. For example, Third Sector Company integrates AI-driven communication insights to refine organisational messaging and tailor content to varied audiences. Manage HR Magazine ’s Top Interim Services Provider award recognised Third Sector Company for advancing personalised, hybrid-ready communication strategies and support models. For instance, companies can filter and personalize messages based on different teams and divisions, seniority levels, nations, or even individuals with certain business benefits. Applying AI-based employer branding and copywriting tools to create communication and notification message templates helps enhance personalization. Businesses can write faster, save time, and scale their efforts more quickly. Creating a Fine Balance Although it helps increase employee engagement, technology is not the objective in itself. Ensuring employees feel valued and motivated still requires a personal approach and human connection. This will help in improving engagement and retention. Rapid innovations in HR technology make it a terrific tool for fostering a customized employee experience. It just constitutes a portion of a more comprehensive solution, and managers must also take an active part. They must understand the diverse needs of employees within the organization to effectively utilize technology in designing an inclusive and considerate employee experience. ...Read more
Society’s expectations are evolving alongside rapid technological advancements, leading to significant transformations in the leadership landscape. Organizations seeking to keep up with unprecedented change now require leaders who inspire, guide and cultivate environments emphasizing innovation, inclusivity, and well-being. The future of leadership focuses on adapting to new paradigms that empower individuals while achieving organizational goals. The Importance of Emotional Intelligence and DEI One of the most important shifts in leadership is the growing emphasis on emotional intelligence and empathy. Modern leaders are called to connect with their teams, recognizing each individual’s unique needs and motivations. This focus on empathy cultivates a positive organizational culture and enhances employee engagement and loyalty. A workforce that feels valued is not only more productive but also more innovative. Diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) have become foundational values within contemporary leadership. Today’s leaders must actively create workplaces that reflect diverse perspectives, acknowledging that such diversity fuels creativity and innovation. It’s no longer just a matter of representation; integrating DEI into organizational strategies has become a moral responsibility and a catalyst for economic success, ensuring that all voices are heard and valued. Navigating the Digital Age and Sustainability The digital revolution is another critical factor reshaping the role of leaders. As automation, artificial intelligence, and remote work redefine professional landscapes, leaders must harness technological advancements to enhance team collaboration and productivity. This requires fostering digital literacy and finding the right balance between human intuition and technological tools, allowing organizations to thrive amid rapid changes. Furthermore, sustainability has emerged as a vital consideration in leadership strategies. With increasing environmental challenges, leaders must incorporate sustainable practices into their operations, aligning business objectives with ecological responsibility. By prioritizing eco-friendly initiatives, leaders contribute to a healthier planet and build brand credibility and loyalty among environmentally conscious consumers. Embracing Lifelong Learning and Purpose-Driven Leadership In this fast-evolving environment, flexibility and lifelong learning have become essential traits for leaders. Embracing curiosity and openness to new ideas will foster an innovative and resilient organizational culture. Leaders must continuously seek new skills and encourage their teams to do the same, ensuring they remain competitive and adaptable. Purpose-driven leadership is also gaining traction as employees increasingly desire to work for organizations that align with their values and contribute to meaningful causes. Leaders can boost morale, enhance organizational reputation, and promote long-term success by connecting everyday tasks to larger goals. As we move toward an interconnected future, leaders who demonstrate adaptability, empathy, inclusivity, and a commitment to purpose will guide their organizations to success amidst complexity and change. ...Read more
Offices across the country have begun to open again after over a year of remote operations and virtual communication, and many adopting a hybrid work strategy. Whether individually or virtually , connecting and communicating with others remains an essential skill in this new working age. Three ways to facilitate effective communication in a hybrid work environment are provided: Keep Eye contact Whether you are in a video call, meeting a colleague at the office, eye contact can look challenging or even unnatural if you talk to someone. But still, eye contact is an effective connection tool. It can not only help you to make an impact on your message, but it also shows colleagues that you listen carefully. BeArticulate There are times when you communicate with people in person and virtually simultaneously within the new hybrid working environment. It may at first be difficult to communicate with two different types of audiences. One way to manage it is through your voice. Good speech articulation, so you speak clearer, helps to get your message across. For people who listen via video call, this is especially helpful. Maintain Connection You may think that while working from home, you missed important talks and even simple casual calls into the office. Hybrid work provides additional opportunities to connect to and participate in your team, such as stopping for a chat with colleagues or participating in virtual projects with home staff. See Also: Top 10 HR Tech Consulting/Service Companies ...Read more
Unemployment costs have evolved from a routine HR expense into a strategic financial variable that directly affects profitability, workforce planning, and enterprise risk management. In volatile labor markets characterized by restructuring cycles, automation, economic slowdowns, and regulatory complexity, organizations face increasing pressure to control unemployment insurance taxes, claims liabilities, and compliance exposure. CEOs can no longer treat unemployment cost management as a back-office administrative function. Companies that proactively manage unemployment costs strengthen financial predictability, protect employer reputation, and build workforce agility in uncertain economic environments. Growth Drivers and Escalating Financial Exposure Market contractions, sector disruptions, and global supply chain realignments frequently trigger workforce reductions. Each separation potentially impacts unemployment insurance tax rates and claims histories, increasing long-term financial liability. Workforce transformation contributes to cost volatility. Automation, AI integration, and digital transformation initiatives reshape job roles and eliminate redundant positions. While these transitions drive productivity gains, they often create short-term unemployment claims that affect experience ratings and state tax obligations. The expansion of remote and gig-based employment models adds complexity. Multi-state employment arrangements expose organizations to varying unemployment tax regulations, reporting requirements, and benefit eligibility criteria. Without centralized oversight, companies risk inconsistent compliance and unnecessary penalties. Regulatory shifts further elevate exposure. Governments frequently adjust unemployment insurance contribution formulas, wage bases, and eligibility standards in response to economic conditions. Organizations that fail to monitor policy changes face unexpected increases in payroll tax obligations. Litigation and contested claims represent another cost driver. Improper termination documentation, inconsistent performance management practices, and inadequate disciplinary records often result in successful unemployment claims that could have been mitigated. Each approved claim increases experience ratings and future tax contributions. These factors translate into unpredictable cost structures. Effective unemployment cost management requires forecasting models that align workforce planning with financial risk assessment. Technology Integration and Data-Driven Controls Technology now plays a central role in controlling unemployment-related expenses. Advanced workforce analytics platforms enable organizations to model separation trends, predict claim exposure, and simulate financial impact scenarios. By integrating HR data with payroll systems, companies can identify departments with higher turnover risk and implement preventive interventions. Automated claims management systems streamline response processes. Timely and accurate submission of documentation significantly improves success rates in contested claims. Digital workflows reduce administrative delays and ensure compliance with state-specific deadlines. AI enhances risk assessment by analyzing termination patterns, performance metrics, and dispute histories. Predictive algorithms flag cases with elevated claim approval probability, allowing legal and HR teams to prepare evidence proactively. Centralized compliance dashboards provide executive visibility into tax rate changes, regulatory updates, and claims outcomes across jurisdictions. This real-time transparency empowers leadership to make informed workforce decisions while maintaining financial discipline. Outsourcing partnerships represent a technological and strategic advancement. Specialized unemployment cost management providers leverage proprietary analytics and regulatory expertise to reduce claims frequency and improve appeal outcomes. Organizations that integrate external expertise into their governance models often achieve measurable tax savings. Cloud-based documentation systems further strengthen compliance posture. Maintaining consistent performance reviews, disciplinary records, and termination rationale ensures that organizations can defend separation decisions effectively. Strong documentation culture reduces claim approval rates and long-term cost escalation. Operational Strategy and Organizational Transformation Strategic unemployment cost management requires alignment between workforce planning and financial governance. CEOs should integrate unemployment exposure into broader risk management frameworks, treating it as a measurable financial KPI rather than an incidental expense. Proactive workforce planning minimizes reactive layoffs. Scenario-based planning models allow leadership to anticipate market fluctuations and adjust hiring strategies accordingly. Redeployment initiatives and reskilling programs can reduce involuntary separations while preserving institutional knowledge. Performance management systems play a preventive role. Clear job expectations, structured feedback cycles, and documented improvement plans reduce ambiguity during separations. Consistent processes across departments ensure defensible employment decisions. Training frontline managers in termination protocols significantly lowers claim risks. Managers must understand documentation standards, legal compliance requirements, and communication best practices. Well-executed separation processes decrease disputes and reputational harm. Financial forecasting models should incorporate unemployment tax rate projections. By analyzing historical claims data and anticipated workforce changes, CFOs can allocate reserves accurately and avoid budgetary surprises. Cross-functional collaboration enhances operational efficiency. HR, finance, legal, and operations teams must share data and coordinate decision-making. Integrated governance structures prevent siloed actions that inadvertently increase exposure. Employer branding also indirectly influences unemployment costs. Organizations with strong engagement cultures and transparent communication often experience lower contested claim rates. Offering transition support, severance packages, and career counseling can reduce claim frequency and protect corporate reputation. Unemployment cost management has evolved into a strategic executive priority. Economic volatility, regulatory complexity, and workforce transformation amplify financial exposure. Advanced analytics, automation, and compliance integration enable proactive control. Operational alignment across HR, finance, and legal strengthens resilience and predictability. ...Read more